edlorah
location: The Recession Will Not Be Televised
listening to: http://www.instantrimshot.com/
registered: 1999.12.27
posts: 3664
[view all posts]
[view all posts]
One of my best friends is a Dawkins/Harris/Hitchens fan to the point that he's now kind of an 'atheist
fundamentalist': intolerant of anyone who believes in anything they can't see, smell, touch, taste, etc;
I read Sam Harris at his urging last year and found Harris to be a poor historian, an apologist for
torture by the Bush administration, and a kind of intellectual 'one-trick pony'. A shockingly vacant
rant on religion that shed more heat than light, designed only to fire up readers already well-prepared
to swallow Harris' screed and earn him a million bucks.
We're all (well, most of us are) sick of fundamentalists of every stripe gumming up the works. But
substituting one form of intellectual dishonesty for another is not going to advance anybody's cause,
except for the author's who whip this stuff out for the mob.
If you want to read a reasonable discourse on modern fundamentalism I'd suggest Karen
Armstrong's
"The Battle For God". Armstrong is a meticulous researcher and an engaging writer, but if you're
looking for someone who panders to what you already think you know it may be a more demanding
read.
–--
"It was done only for political reasons only anyway. "
"It was done only for political reasons only anyway. "
E
edlorah
(view)
One of my best friends is a Dawkins/Harris/Hitchens fan to the point that he's now kind of an 'atheist
fundamentalist': intolerant of anyone who believes in anything they can't see, smell, touch, taste, etc;
I read Sam Harris at his urging last year and found Harris to be a poor historian, an apologist for
torture by the Bush administration, and a kind of intellectual 'one-trick pony'. A shockingly vacant
rant on religion that shed more heat than light, designed only to fire up readers already well-prepared
to swallow Harris' screed and earn him a million bucks.
We're all (well, most of us are) sick of fundamentalists of every stripe gumming up the works. But
substituting one form of intellectual dishonesty for another is not going to advance anybody's cause,
except for the author's who whip this stuff out for the mob.
If you want to read a reasonable discourse on modern fundamentalism I'd suggest Karen
Armstrong's
"The Battle For God". Armstrong is a meticulous researcher and an engaging writer, but if you're
looking for someone who panders to what you already think you know it may be a more demanding
read.
–--
"It was done only for political reasons only anyway. "
"It was done only for political reasons only anyway. "
posted 2008.06.30
posted on June 30th 2008
E
edlorah
location: The Recession Will Not Be Televised
listening to: http://www.instantrimshot.com/
registered: 1999.12.27
posts: 3664
[view all posts]
[view all posts]
-
If We Attack Iran ( A Worst Case Scenario) – Peter T. on June 28th, 2008-
Re: If We Attack Iran ( A Worst Case Scenario) – blockdog on June 28th, 2008-
Re: If We Attack Iran ( A Worst Case Scenario) – Baerwald on June 28th, 2008-
Christian Jihadists ..... – PatBrown on June 28th, 2008-
Re: Christian Jihadists ..... – Baerwald on June 28th, 2008-
Re: Christian Jihadists .....religion and power - modern theocracy.... – Lee on June 29th, 2008-
Re: Christian Jihadists .....religion and power - modern theocracy.... – PatBrown on June 29th, 2008
Re: Christian Jihadists .....religion and power - modern theocracy.... – Herring405 on June 29th, 2008
Gee, Lee, Pat is a Moonie... – Reg on June 29th, 2008-
Re: Gee, Lee, Pat is a Moonie... – Lee on June 30th, 2008-
Re: Gee, Lee, Pat is a Moonie... – Reg on June 30th, 2008
Re: Gee, Lee, Pat is a Moonie... – rosskolnikov on June 30th, 2008
Let me ask you David – PatBrown on June 29th, 2008-
Re: Let me ask you David – stark raving brad on June 29th, 2008-
"The One", SRB? – Peter T. on June 29th, 2008-
OMG – stark raving brad on June 29th, 2008-
OMG – Peter T. on June 29th, 2008-
Re: OMG – stark raving brad on June 30th, 2008
I don't believe in Sam Harris – edlorah on June 30th, 2008-
Re: I don't believe in Sam Harris – rosskolnikov on June 30th, 2008-
Great thread! – Reg on June 30th, 2008-
Re: Great thread! – edlorah on June 30th, 2008-
Re: Great thread! – Reg on June 30th, 2008-
Re: Great thread! – stark raving brad on June 30th, 2008
Re: I don't believe in Sam Harris – edlorah on July 1st, 2008-
Re: I don't believe in Sam Harris – rosskolnikov on July 1st, 2008
The One, SRB – blockdog on June 30th, 2008
The One, SRB ( Yo Messy ) – blockdog on June 30th, 2008
Re: Let me ask you David – Herring405 on June 29th, 2008
Re: Let me ask you (David) – rosskolnikov on June 30th, 2008-
Re: Let me ask you (David) – edlorah on June 30th, 2008
Remember Rossi – PatBrown on July 1st, 2008-
Re: Remember Rossi – Herring405 on July 1st, 2008-
Re: Remember Rossi – PatBrown on July 1st, 2008-
Re: Remember Rossi – Herring405 on July 1st, 2008-
Re: Remember Rossi – PatBrown on July 1st, 2008-
Re: Remember Rossi – Herring405 on July 1st, 2008
Re: Remember Rossi – stark raving brad on July 1st, 2008
All Hat, No Cattle – edlorah on July 1st, 2008
Re: Remember . . . – rosskolnikov on July 1st, 2008
Re: Christian Jihadists ..... – nks422 on July 1st, 2008
Re: If We Attack Iran ( A Worst Case Scenario) – Reg on June 28th, 2008-
Re: If We Attack Iran ( A Worst Case Scenario) – mick on June 29th, 2008
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
