rosskolnikov
location: Far end of the Group W bench
listening to: The Tony Rice Unit
registered: 2005.05.24
posts: 1822
[view all posts]
[view all posts]
Depends on the group. When I hear the "sacred" comment, it's often from Catholics who (officially)
oppose capital punishment. With other groups, they talk more about "not killing innocents" and thus
leave room for killing as a punishment and after legal review. They are two different cases, however
finely split are the hairs. The counter to your argument might be: if life is NOT sacred, then why punish murder or
manslaughter? Seems to me the real issue is still when that fetus acquires its own legal personhood. From a scientific
point of view, it seems to me that this would either be at birth or at "fetal viability," whatever that may
be. A reasonable debate can be had around that issue, but I never hear it discussed in those terms.
–--
.:RS:.
.:RS:.
R
rosskolnikov
(view)
Depends on the group. When I hear the "sacred" comment, it's often from Catholics who (officially)
oppose capital punishment. With other groups, they talk more about "not killing innocents" and thus
leave room for killing as a punishment and after legal review. They are two different cases, however
finely split are the hairs. The counter to your argument might be: if life is NOT sacred, then why punish murder or
manslaughter? Seems to me the real issue is still when that fetus acquires its own legal personhood. From a scientific
point of view, it seems to me that this would either be at birth or at "fetal viability," whatever that may
be. A reasonable debate can be had around that issue, but I never hear it discussed in those terms.
–--
.:RS:.
.:RS:.
posted 2012.10.30
posted on October 30th 2012
R
rosskolnikov
location: Far end of the Group W bench
listening to: The Tony Rice Unit
registered: 2005.05.24
posts: 1822
[view all posts]
[view all posts]
-
Here is probably the worst thing about the Romney Campaign.... – EEE on October 28th, 2012-
Re: Here is probably the worst thing about the Romney Campaign.... – MJG on October 28th, 2012
Re: Here is probably the worst thing about the Romney Campaign.... – rosskolnikov on October 28th, 2012-
Re: Here is probably the worst thing about the Romney Campaign.... – Andrea on October 29th, 2012-
Re: Here is probably the worst thing about the Romney Campaign.... – rosskolnikov on October 29th, 2012-
A contradiction I've never seen a suitable answer for... – EEE on October 29th, 2012-
Re: A contradiction I've never seen a suitable answer for... – Dslacker on October 29th, 2012
Re: A contradiction I've never seen a suitable answer for... – rosskolnikov on October 30th, 2012-
Still..... – EEE on October 30th, 2012
-
-
-
-
